Two faced or what?
Moderators: DJKeefy, 4u Network
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
Two faced or what?
Whilst reading a thread on the blue side, a mention was made of Copts being attacked in Egypt because they were praying in an unauthorised place, that place being a house. Now forgive my ignorance on the matter but surely as anyone travelling the world or living in Europe or the UK will have observed, muslims can be seen dropping a prayer mat in any location that they find suitable and carrying out their devotions.
So my question is this: Why is that a suitable practice for a Muslim, but a Christian cannot pray in someones home unless it is authorised? or am I missing something here?
So my question is this: Why is that a suitable practice for a Muslim, but a Christian cannot pray in someones home unless it is authorised? or am I missing something here?
- HEPZIBAH
- Top Member
- Posts: 664
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: Uk
- Has thanked: 12 times
- Been thanked: 7 times
- Gender:
[face=Comic Sans MS]Horus, this is a question that I frequently wonder about. I get very frustrated too at times about the total freedom in the UK (sorry I've not put that well and I know given current feelings many will accuse me of not being, at best, politically correct!) for anyone to worship whoever they wish and wherever they wish. My frustration comes mainly because whilst I have no objection to a Muslim or a follower of another faith to worship in the UK, I think the same courtesy should be extended to Christians in other countries.
Public worship and prayer meetings for Christians are forbidden in many countries, or are 'tolerated and monitored' extreemly closely by the authorities as in China, so whilst not fully banned are not really allowed. I recall many years ago taking part in a prayer meeting in Algeria, where we had to meet at a secret location a long way out of town. On that occasion there where around 60 people present, at least 40 which were Algerian nationals. It was not the safest place to be for we Europeans, but it was deadly for those Algerians but they were so happy to be able to meet with other Christians from their own country and around the world that to them it was worth the risk. Certainly a Christian gathering of that number of people had not taken place in that area for very many years, if ever. [/face]
Public worship and prayer meetings for Christians are forbidden in many countries, or are 'tolerated and monitored' extreemly closely by the authorities as in China, so whilst not fully banned are not really allowed. I recall many years ago taking part in a prayer meeting in Algeria, where we had to meet at a secret location a long way out of town. On that occasion there where around 60 people present, at least 40 which were Algerian nationals. It was not the safest place to be for we Europeans, but it was deadly for those Algerians but they were so happy to be able to meet with other Christians from their own country and around the world that to them it was worth the risk. Certainly a Christian gathering of that number of people had not taken place in that area for very many years, if ever. [/face]
Experience is not what happens to you;
it is what you do with what happens to you.
-Aldous Huxley
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
Forget being politically correct Hepzi I for one am sick of the having to kow tow to every diverse grouping in the name of political correctness. General acceptance is what we need, I accept your views and you accept mine. If I live in your country I try to obey your laws, please do the same in mine. Assimilation not segregation, tolerance and not ignorance, but it must apply all round. There may be some things that you are not to keen on about my culture, but you must accept that the same will apply to your own culture and practices. If we are tolerant of each other then peace will prevail, it is when one faction decides it will impose its (usually religious) views upon another that the trouble starts.
It's true
Copts are only allowed to worship in authorised churches and to get the permission to build a new Church or even do repairs to an old one takes ages and is often refused. For this reason they sometimes use other buildings temporarily and this is when the problems have started. They can of course pray in their own homes but if they gather in a group this is when problems can start.
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
It should n't happen but it does!
I was n't saying it was justified, far from it but that's just the situation. Look at some of the other posts further down this page to see some of the other recent incidents.
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
Re: It should n't happen but it does!
Oh I did not think that you were Claire I was just posing the question of wouldn't it be an intolerant thing to do to the Copts.Claire wrote:I was n't saying it was justified, far from it but that's just the situation. Look at some of the other posts further down this page to see some of the other recent incidents.
Are the other posts you refer to on the blue side?
Yes you are a slow starter Horus.
What you need to do is start up a single race exclusive association, there are plenty out there, ie if you are a white man and Christian then let me suggest.
The White Christian Male Movement for Equality T.W.C.M.E and have it legalized through Parliament and if they reject it as being racist tell them they are not being politically correct and you will take it to Brussels and then your good to go. It'll be perfectly legal to worship in your home.
I think you'll find that soon everyone will be on that bandwagon.
If you can't beat them join them
What you need to do is start up a single race exclusive association, there are plenty out there, ie if you are a white man and Christian then let me suggest.
The White Christian Male Movement for Equality T.W.C.M.E and have it legalized through Parliament and if they reject it as being racist tell them they are not being politically correct and you will take it to Brussels and then your good to go. It'll be perfectly legal to worship in your home.
I think you'll find that soon everyone will be on that bandwagon.
If you can't beat them join them
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
Ah yes I see your point now sorry, I am being a bit thick today
I have to say that unfortunately that does seem to happen quite a lot in the UK, any excuse to play the racist card. The down side of course is that eventually people stop beating themselves with the political correctness stick and start to react against it.
This I fear is already starting to show itself in the election of such parties as the BNP, politicians will stick their heads in the sand and say that it is just another protest against the government but they could not be more wrong.
My greatest fear is that the previous level of tolerance shown with regards to immigration and integration in the UK in particular will cease to be so while normally tolerant people feel that they are always having to accommodate others beliefs and customs to what they perceive to be their own detriment.
I have to say that unfortunately that does seem to happen quite a lot in the UK, any excuse to play the racist card. The down side of course is that eventually people stop beating themselves with the political correctness stick and start to react against it.
This I fear is already starting to show itself in the election of such parties as the BNP, politicians will stick their heads in the sand and say that it is just another protest against the government but they could not be more wrong.
My greatest fear is that the previous level of tolerance shown with regards to immigration and integration in the UK in particular will cease to be so while normally tolerant people feel that they are always having to accommodate others beliefs and customs to what they perceive to be their own detriment.
Other stories of problems
Horus
There are two other threads in this section here by DJ Keefey which talk about some of the problems experienced by Copts. There are also some others on the blue forum.
There are two other threads in this section here by DJ Keefey which talk about some of the problems experienced by Copts. There are also some others on the blue forum.
- Glyphdoctor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 263
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Has thanked: 5 times
- Been thanked: 4 times
Under emergency law, regardless of your religion, you are not allowed to meet in groups in Egypt. If you want to have a meeting of more than 5 people, technically you are required to get a permit from the government.
Nothing is going to change if these problems keep being cast as problems that apply to Copts only. If the Copts want their rights, they need to start admitting that Muslims have the same problems in Egypt and join forces with them rather than act antagonistic about it. Being divided is no good for anyone.
Nothing is going to change if these problems keep being cast as problems that apply to Copts only. If the Copts want their rights, they need to start admitting that Muslims have the same problems in Egypt and join forces with them rather than act antagonistic about it. Being divided is no good for anyone.
Permits for Churches
Yes the emergency laws apply to all BUT getting a permit for a new Church or even Church repairs is a nightmare. It is not the same process to build a mosque. Mosques can and do spring up everywhere. No way are the Copts and Muslims treated equally when it comes to places of worship. This is the root of these problems with people praying in buildings not yet authorised. In the incidents mentioned it was the local population who started to complain about the Copts praying not the security police.
- Horus
- Egypt4u God
- Posts: 12363
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 1658 times
- Been thanked: 2213 times
- Gender:
Five?..........you mean Five as in 1 + 4 ?, that is not even a family sitting down for lunch together, how ridiculous!Under emergency law, regardless of your religion, you are not allowed to meet in groups in Egypt. If you want to have a meeting of more than 5 people, technically you are required to get a permit from the government.
Looks like we will have to be more careful with our L4U meetings in future
- Glyphdoctor
- Senior Member
- Posts: 263
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 2:15 am
- Has thanked: 5 times
- Been thanked: 4 times
Re: Permits for Churches
Doesn't the Coptic Church have the right to choose its own clergy though? The government took over all the mosques and put imams of their choosing in place. The issues facing the Copts are different but the fact is that the government plays a dominant role in determining how one can worship in this country regardless of the religion of the worshipper. What about the Shia in Egypt?Claire wrote: No way are the Copts and Muslims treated equally when it comes to places of worship.
Up to a point!
Yes the Copts can choose their own clergy altho there was a nasty incident some years back when the current Head of the Coptic Church was ordered by the goverment to stay in his monastery and the government tried but failed to put another Bishop in his place! The government do keep a close eye on the clergy though and outspoken ones are soon told to keep quiet!!! Yes the 'emergency' rules apply to all in one way or another!